Last weekend, Dave and I attended The Beard of Avon - a play based on the assumption that Shakespeare was NOT the real author of his plays, but a front-man for other various writers who wished to remain anonymous. (we enjoyed the play - witty, humorous, thought-provoking).
After the play, Dave and I had the following discussion:
Dave - Well, if you really think about it, there is NO way one man could have written all those plays and sonnets.
Me - Why not? Look at Mozart and what he accomplished in his short lifetime. Shakespeare was a genius and very talented. It is totally possible.
Dave - Composing music is totally different than writing literature. Writing comes from experiences and there is NO WAY that one man experienced all those different scenarios.
Me - WHAT?!? Writing comes from imagination. Do you think that all those Sci-Fi and Fantasy authors experienced what they've written about?
Dave - (laughing) I bet Isaac Asimov was abducted by aliens, several times.
Me - Seriously, Dave. Fiction comes from imagination. Did Shakespeare need to kill a man to write about it? No. Did he have to be stranded on an island to write about it? No.
Dave - Sure an author writes from imagination - but no matter what, all writing has basis on what they've experienced.
Me - Come on. I can tell you right now that when I wrote in my book about a demon ripping apart one of my characters, I have NEVER experienced that in my lifetime.
Dave - No, but the settings, the surroundings, and some of the characters are all from your experience.
Me - So, what are you saying then? Shakespeare couldn't have written about Vernonia because he had never been there?
Dave - Yes...and it's Verona. Vernonia is a town in Oregon.
Me - oh....well, I could write about Africa not having ever been there.
Dave - You have access to the internet, tv, and books that show you what Africa looks like. Thus, that is your experience. That is what you draw from.
Me - Shakespeare could have met people from Verona who told him about it.
Dave - Maybe. But I agree with the theory. I doubt one man wrote all those plays. They are masterpieces, every single one. How many can one person come up with?
Me - Look at Stephen King. He has written a TON of books.
Dave - Stephen King's books are NOT masterpieces. They are general fiction for the masses.
Me - Okay, you are right about that. Actually, I doubt Shakespeare wrote it all. I was just playing Devil's Advocate....but I still think it is possible. Imagination is an incredible thing.
So, what is your opinion on this? Was Shakespeare the author of the material? Can an author write strictly from imagination without including their own experiences? Inquiring minds want to know (actually, just mine).